Best Cookies For Shipping (2024)

This post may contain affiliate sales links. Please see my full disclosure policy for details

Here are 13 of the Best Cookies for Shipping plus lots of tips for how to package your cookies to mail them and keep them fresh. Whether it’s Christmas or not, shipping cookies is easier than you think!

If you’re at all like me, than you enjoy shipping cookies and other baked goods to friends and family. I think this is one of the best ways to show them that you care. Whether they’re Christmas Cookies or just a surprise for a friend, there are plenty of amazing cookies can be shipped. I’ve included lots of tips for how to pack your cookies, what types of containers to use and how to prepare your cookies for shipping. Do you have any tips you would like to share? Please let me me know!

TABLE OF CONTENTS

How to prepare your cookies for shipping
How to pack cookies for shipping
What type of container should I use to ship cookies?
Can I ship cookies with chocolate?
Classic Christmas Cookies
Peppermint and Mint Cookies
Shortbread Cookies
Bark Recipes
Oatmeal Cookies
Pudding Cookies

How to prepare your cookies for shipping

It is important that you consider the type of cookies that you are shipping. Will they be able to hold their shape when they are shipped? Is there a need to place parchment paper between each layer? Sometimes when cookies are too large, it can be difficult to package them.

Usually when I am making a batch of cookie that are going to be shipped, I use my medium-sized cookie scoop. Not only will this produce a higher yield from your batch of cookies but it will make it easier to fit more cookies in your container.

How do I keep my cookies fresh? Once the cookies are baked and cooled, I always flash freeze them. To do this, I place the cookies on a baking sheet or in a freezer-safe containerwithout the cover, which allows the cookies to freeze and no additional moisture to build up. Once they are frozen, I store them in an airtight container until I am ready to ship them.

I like to ship my cookies frozen, so I pack my containers and leave them in the freezer until I am ready to send them out. This just helps keep them fresh a little bit longer. Whenever possible, I ship 1-2 days express to ensure the cookies will still be fresh when they arrive.

How to pack cookies for shipping

I thought that Sally’s tip for shipping cookieswas pretty unique. She wraps two cookies together in saran wrap with the bottom of the cookies touching each other. This is not the way I ship my cookies, but it’s pretty dang cleaver.

When shipping multiple types of cookies, I will sometimes place each flavor of cookie in a separate small Ziploc bag. This is especially important if you have peppermint cookies in your container, because the flavor can be overpowering and you do not want all your other cookies to absorb that flavor. I find that this also helps keep the cookies fresher for long, especially if you’re using a cookie tin that is not airtight.

Try to fill the space as best as possible to prevent the cookies from moving around while in transit. This is the best way to prevent your cookies from breaking or crumbling. Sometimes I like to use fillers like Hershey’s Kisses or other candies to fill in the gaps. One of my favorite things to do is use my miniature cookie cutters and make some bite-sized sugar cookies as well.

What type of container should I use to ship cookies?

It’s important that you find the right size container to ship your cookies. I love cute cookie packaging as much as the next person, but it isn’t always economical for shipping. They can get crushed and they usually aren’t airtight, so you’re losing some freshness there too.

Instead, I opt for seasonal cookie tins and colored Ziploc containers. Ziploc containers are definitely not the most prettiest, but you can dress them up. Consider placing some white tissue paper in the bottom of your container and then wrap the container with some bakers twine or ribbon.

Pack the cookies safely inside of the box surrounded by bubble wrap or additional packing paper and be sure the container tightly packed inside your box. I also like to write “fragile” on the outside of the box.

Can I ship cookies with chocolate?

In general, cookies that are dipped or covered in chocolate should not be shipped during the warmer months. Usually Christmas is a fine time to ship chocolate-dipped treats because a majority of the country is experiencing colder weather. You just need to consider to where your cookies are being shipped. It is always a good idea to ship these by 1-2 day express.

If you’re unsure, you can always include an ice pack or two in your box, but be sure your container is plastic or aluminum and that it’s securely sealed so as not to let in any additional moisture.

Now that we’ve address all of your burning question for thebest way to ship cookies, let’s take a look at the actual cookies that I like to send. I’ve included all types of cookies that I’ve shipped before including classic Christmas cookies both peppermint flavored and non-peppermint flavored, Shortbread cookies and Bark recipes. I also included some pudding cookies and some oatmeal cookies that are a little less “Christmas” themed recipes. Happy baking!